Evertrue
32 Case Studies
A Evertrue Case Study
Chicago Theological Seminary faced a challenge with its annual fund, as traditional, short-form fundraising communications were not meeting performance expectations. Supporters wanted more substantive content and a deeper connection to the institution's mission. To address this, they partnered with Evertrue and used its Pledgemine service to evolve their strategy.
By using Evertrue's Pledgemine, the seminary implemented a mission-driven direct mail strategy featuring longer-form, content-rich storytelling. This solution led to a 12% response rate, clear spikes in online giving following mail drops, and highly positive qualitative feedback from donors. Evertrue enabled the team to successfully shift from transactional asks to meaningful engagement, strengthening the donor community.